Through It All, It's Still About the Workers
Anirban Basu is the Chairman & CEO of Sage Policy Group and Chief Economist of the Modular Building Institute.
It wasn’t supposed to be this way. A flurry of interest rate increases engineered by the Federal Reserve in 2022 and 2023 was intended to dramatically soften U.S. economic conditions, with particular impact anticipated for interest rate sensitive segments like real estate, homebuilding and nonresidential construction. While many contractors would not have been expected to be enamored with the associated loss of demand for their services, at least the presence of smaller backlog would entail suffering less intensely from America’s shortage of skilled construction workers.
Alas, things rarely work out as expected. All things being equal, higher interest rates have suppressed demand for construction services, at least in certain segments. But all things are not equal. For instance, the coming of age of Millennials, America’s largest generation, has accelerated household formation and expanded demand for housing. While elevated mortgage rates (by Millennial standards – the oldest of that generation turns 44 this year) have diminished opportunities for Millennials to purchase homes, they have likely induced more members of the generation to lease apartments. Not surprisingly, apartment construction has been elevated, though several indicators suggest that that has begun to slow.
Anirban Basu speaks at the Modular Building Institute's annual World of Modular conference.
Other factors have kept contractors busy. A tsunami of public funds has fueled construction of schools, roads, bridges, water/sewer systems, and other public works. The growing pervasiveness of artificial intelligence and general expansion of digital footprints has expanded the need for data centers. The nation’s push towards new forms of energy has also fueled construction worker demand, with many states implementing ambitious goals for transition to renewables irrespective of cost.
Reshoring of supply chains to America has perhaps been the single most important factor in creating new demand for construction services during the last several years. Reshoring is transpiring in the context of geopolitical tensions between the U.S. and China, the world’s two largest economies (by far), a desire for simplified logistics among manufacturers and distributors, and massive federal subsidies to manufacturers willing to add domestic production capacity in key segments has unleashed dozens of megaprojects around the nation. In short, production capacity is coming back to America in a large way, whether with respect to semiconductor, battery, or EV production. All these things and more have rendered America’s construction firms far busier than many economists expected them to be.
Among the implications is that if anything demand for skilled construction workers has expanded during a period of elevated financing costs. By February 2024, the number of available, unfilled construction job openings had reached an all-time high. At some point, interest rates will fall, creating another surge in demand for such workers. In short, solving the nation’s skilled worker shortage issue has never been more important.
What the Data Say
According to the latest data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the total number of construction jobs in the U.S. stood at 8.2 million as of April 2024. On a year-over-year basis, the number of jobs had expanded by 3.2 percent. By comparison, the total number of jobs economywide grew 1.8 percent. Not coincidentally, wages have also been on the rise. Prior to the pandemic, average hourly earnings in construction stood at $31.38. As of April, it was $38.02, an increase of 21.2 percent in approximately four years.
It is true that the number of construction job openings has been declining recently, likely a response to the impact of higher interest rates on project starts. When the Federal Reserve began raising rates in March 2022, it was doing so off an extraordinarily low base of interest rates. It took several interest rate increases before rates were high enough to have bite. In the interim, another set of construction projects was planned, financed, and started. It appears that interest rates have now been high enough for long enough to blunt a certain level of activity.
According to data from the Jobs Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS), the number of construction job openings was 25,000 lower this April than last, with a meaningful decline in openings since February. As of this writing, the industry is associated with 338,000 available, unfilled job openings.
Many observers would indicate that a new phenomenon has already begun to solve the construction worker shortfall – immigration. The rush across America’s southern border has indeed expanded the size of the nation’s labor force. There are several industries closely associated with immigration of this type, including agriculture and construction. It is conceivable that the recent decline in construction job openings is attributable not only to higher project financing costs, but also to the ability of some contractors to fill openings with new migrants.
However, many of these newcomers lack not only documentation, but also the specific skills required to work with electrical or other forms of equipment. In other words, while immigration may help resolve some of the worker shortage, it does relatively less to solve the skilled worker shortage.
Some Novel Ideas
Traditional thinking regarding addressing the skilled construction worker shortage has focused on apprenticeship programs, two-year colleges, and vocational high schools. Those institutions remain hugely important, but in and of themselves have been inadequate to fully rectify the situation. Accordingly, additional ideas are needed.
Governor Janet Mills of Maine recently signed an executive order that would promote the training and recruitment of more women into construction. That such industry concerns would rise to the level of governor is impressive. Presently, women hold only 15 percent of the state’s construction jobs. The executive order would direct state agencies to identify barriers women face with respect to entering the industry. The order will also better connect employers with women presently immersed in pre-apprenticeship programs, apprenticeship programs, or in relevant post-secondary educational programs.
Maine has also directed a sizable amount of funding towards promoting women in trade-related fields. In 2022, the Governor signed the Maine Jobs & Recovery Plan, directing $12 million in funding towards apprenticeship programs. It also allocated $25 million towards Career and Technical Education programs.
There are other ideas. The emergence of new construction technologies stands to be of enormous appeal to younger workers, who prefer working in state-of-the-art contexts. Ongoing concerns regarding student debt also have many families searching for alternatives to the traditional borrow-and-educate model. Skilled construction trades offer precisely that type of alternative. Finally, there is on-the-job training. Taken altogether, it may be that the incoming unskilled workers of today will emerge as the highly skilled and entrepreneurial professionals of tomorrow.
More from Modular Advantage
Modern Desert Oasis: Building Reset Hotel the Modular Way
While the off-site construction part of the Reset Hotel project has been carefully controlled and with every necessity close at hand at BECC Modular’s factory in Ontario, Canada, the remote location of the project site has created additional challenges for the on site portion of the build.
Revisiting Yellowstone Canyon Village—a Groundbreaking Modular Construction Feat—Ten Years On
With such a short building period due to impending cold, it made the most sense for park developer Xanterra to pursue modular. Yellowstone’s high visitor traffic also required some odd transportation scheduling, as traffic from the West Yellowstone entrance determined the times when trucks could unload modules. Guerdon was up to the challenge.
Built for Brutal Cold, This Modular Office Building Shines
Houlton, the county seat of Aroostook County, Maine, is a small town with a population of about 6,000 residents. Situated along the border between the U.S. and Canada, what the town is most known for is bitterly cold winters. When the U.S. Border Patrol needed new office space, a modular building approach from Modular Genius offered the perfect solution.
Panel Replacement Adds Years of Life to Navy Vessel
Panel Built, Inc., recently replaced all the wall and roof panels on a two-story US Navy barge deck house that the company had originally installed 30 years ago, giving the vessel new life. Now, the commanding officer of the unit that uses the barge said the difference between the condition and appearance from when the barge left their facility to when the project was complete was beyond his expectations of what was possible.
True Modular Building Seeks to Revolutionize Housing. It’s Next Stop: MBI’s World of Modular Europe
True Modular Building (TMB) specializes in crafting attainable, eco-friendly, and comfortable build-to-rent (BTR) housing with modern designs and customizable features, ensuring that residents feel at home both today and tomorrow.
From Toronto to Suriname: A Global Modular Building Story
When I AM Gold – a Canadian gold mining operation based in Toronto, Ontario – wanted to expand its mining operations in Suriname, it knew it would also need to expand its infrastructure. More specifically, they needed to build a mechanical services compound that would allow their local crews to maintain and equipment critical to their mining operations. They also knew that it would be a challenge.
There Were a “Sea of Challenges” for this Modular, Island Development
Question: Can modular construction be used to build a series of affordable, unique housing buildings, all styled to look like they were built in 1845, on an
island that caters to the wealthy? The answer is, of course, yes, but how the
team at Signature Building Systems and KOH Architecture got there is quite a story.
America’s Construction Economy: A Race Against Time
If the economy has been able to handle higher interest rates thus far, undoubtedly it will be able to manage the lower interest rates to come. But many economists are pointing out that the Federal Reserve may already be too late to the game. While they gradually reduce interest rates, the U.S. economy could quickly decelerate, at least based on theoretical grounds if not on the most recent data releases, culminating in that long-predicted recession. Only time will tell.
Top Five Benefits of Modular Office Space
Modular office spaces are transforming how businesses think about their work environments. These innovative structures offer a mix of flexibility, efficiency, and sustainability, making them a smart choice for companies looking to gain an advantage.
Opportunities for Innovation
The construction industry stands at a crossroads. By embracing the principles of industrialized construction, learning from other industries, and harnessing digital technologies, the modular building industry can tackle its major challenges head-on. This transformation promises a future of increased productivity, improved quality, cost control, and a more sustainable, affordable and resilient built environment.